I just watched this on dvd and I really didn’t expect much. Although I knew their was a buzz about this movie being incredible, all my friends that had seen it, hated it or just didn’t see why anybody else thought it was so great. Well, lo and behold, I am one of those who think its great.
As I was watching the film I couldn’t help feeling like I was watching something similar to Hal Ashby’s "Harold and Maude". Not in the story line, just in the general feel and camera shots. The scenes weren’t generally sparse like "Harold and Maude" where there are a lot of scenes of big open rooms with just a table, two chairs, and carefully chosen pictures on the wall, though there were some. Most of the scenes in Garden State were cluttered with stuff on the wall or on desks. And the lighting is a lot darker than in Harold and Maude. But there were so many wide shots where the characters are carefully framed, I got to believe Harold and Maude had to be a big influence. So not quite Harold and Maude, but in a way in which I can’t clearly explain, similar to Harold and Maude. Maybe like this. Wes Anderson would be something like Hal Ashby’s son because his films are so similar it almost seems like plagiarism sometimes and Zack Braff would be something like Hal Ashby’s distant cousin. Little hints of Hal Ashby but mostly doing his own thing.
I loved the opening shots in LA because it is the exact opposite in Swingers where LA is described as "the sun shines here everyday. Its like manifest destiny". Garden State’s LA is cloudy, smoggy, and cold. The traffic isn’t portrayed as a sad joke where ones anger builds up to a rage, it is just sad. Zach Braff’s character Andrew lives in a sparse white room with only a bed and a cell phone. Garden State’s LA is simply drab and unappealing. It is the LA that people actually live in, not the romantic notion portrayed by most films.
I haven’t seen a lot of films with Natalie Portman in it, but as far as I know this is the best performance she has ever given. She seemed like a real person. A real person that is slightly annoying and probably too cute for my liking but a real person. I just don’t think I have ever seen her in a role where she is actually excited and full of life, but it might just be her role in star wars that is my basis of comparison and that probably isn’t saying much.
There are great little stories that seem to be true whenever you leave your hometown and come back years later. There is that friend that ends up being a cop who of all people should not be the one who becomes a cop. There is that person that killed themselves that when you find out about it leaves you amazed but unaffected since you really didn’t know the person anyway. Little details like those make this movie so terrific.
Andrew has a looks are deceiving type friend with Mark played by Peter Sarsgaard. You assume he is a bit of a loser whose life really isn’t going anywhere and doesn’t care that it’s not. He steals jewelry from the people he buries. But a good part of the movie is taking Andrew on a journey to give him a going away gift. He takes back knives that he never purchased to get some money. He uses that money to buy a tank of something I forgot for a hotel employee who lets people peep on people having sex in the hotel’s rooms. The hotel employee then tells him where to go to find the item he is looking for. All very shady, but in him is a simple desire to do something good for a friend. A diamond in the ruff.
There is a romantic relationship that forms between Andrew and Sam that was done incredibly well. It seems that in a lot of movies, action movies in particular, people fall in love in a matter of days, and we all stare at the screen and say to ourselves, "yeah, right!" This has to be the best film to my recollection that has people falling in love in a period of four days where I stare at the screen satisfied and say to myself, "Yeah, I can buy this." When the film ends I completely believed two people had met whom would likely go on to spend the rest of their lives together.
It seemed some people didn’t like this movie because it became a romantic comedy. A road that a lot of folk pass up on just because of the words "romantic comedy". But I don’t think this is what Garden State is about. It’s about a heavily medicated fella who both comes back home after 9 years for his mother’s funeral and gives up the meds before the trip. At 26, after 17 years of being medicated he decides he is gong to start living. Significant and strange things simply just must happen. The relationship between Natalie Portman’s character Sam and Andrew is really just another side story. The real story is how Andrew is changing. It is Andrew answering the question posed at the end of the film, "What do we do now?"
Favorite quote: "Don’t tease me about my hobbies, I don’t tease you about being an asshole."
So Joey and Daniel, if you don't want this movie send it my way becasue I would love to add it to my collection!